How to Pick the Right Genre for Your First Indie Game

So, you want to create your first indie game—but where do you start? One of the most crucial early decisions is picking the right genre. Your choice will affect everything from game mechanics to target audience and even development time. But with so many genres out there, how do you decide? Let’s break it down step by step.

1. Identify Your Strengths and Interests

Before you settle on a genre, consider what you enjoy and where your strengths lie. Ask yourself:

• What types of games do you love playing?

• Do you prefer action-packed gameplay or slower, story-driven experiences?

• Are you more comfortable designing puzzles, combat systems, or exploration mechanics?

Your passion and expertise will directly influence the quality of your game. If you love platformers and understand their mechanics well, developing one will feel more natural than tackling a complex RPG system from scratch.

2. Consider Development Scope and Complexity

Some genres require significantly more time and resources to develop than others. If this is your first indie game, starting with a manageable scope is key. Here’s a rough comparison of genre complexity:

Easier to Develop (Beginner-Friendly Genres)

• Platformers – Simple controls, 2D movement, and well-documented mechanics make this a great starting point.

• Puzzle Games – Focused on logic and design rather than complex animations or AI.

• Top-Down Shooters – Easier to manage than full 3D games, with accessible mechanics.

Moderate Difficulty (Some Experience Needed)

• Metroidvania – Requires strong level design skills and progression planning.

• Turn-Based RPGs – Less technical than action RPGs but require good storytelling and balancing.

• Survival Games – Needs a solid resource and crafting system.

Harder to Develop (Challenging for First-Timers)

• 3D Open-World Games – High asset creation, AI, and large-scale world-building challenges.

• MMORPGs – Networked multiplayer, economy systems, and massive content demands.

• Real-Time Strategy (RTS) – AI pathfinding and balancing make this difficult for beginners.

3. Analyze Market Demand and Competition

While passion is important, you also want to choose a genre with a viable market. Here are some things to consider:

• Check indie success stories: Research what indie games have succeeded recently in different genres.

• Look at competition: Some genres are oversaturated (e.g., roguelikes), making it harder to stand out.

• Follow gaming trends: Genres like cozy farming sims and survival horror have seen increased popularity.

Balancing what you love with market potential can increase your chances of success.

4. Think About Player Experience and Engagement

Every genre offers a different type of player experience. Ask yourself:

• Do you want players to experience fast-paced action (FPS, hack-and-slash)?

• Should they focus on strategy and planning (RTS, simulation)?

• Are you aiming for emotional storytelling (visual novel, adventure games)?

If your goal is to create an immersive story-driven experience, an RPG or visual novel might be ideal. If you want players to test their reflexes, a platformer or shooter would be a better fit.

5. Test a Small Prototype First

Once you have a genre in mind, create a small prototype to test the core mechanics. A simple proof-of-concept will help you determine:

• Whether the gameplay feels fun and engaging.

• How difficult it is to develop with your skill set.

• If adjustments or a genre shift are needed.

Prototyping early saves time and helps refine your game idea before full development.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right genre for your first indie game is a mix of passion, practicality, and market awareness. Start with something manageable, play to your strengths, and test your ideas early. As you grow as a developer, you’ll gain the skills to tackle more ambitious projects.

If you’re still unsure how to create an indie game, start small, experiment, and let your creativity guide you. Every successful developer began somewhere—your first game is just the beginning of the journey!